Skip to main content

Monday, 25 November 2024 | 02:48 pm

|   Subscribe   |   donation   Support Us    |   donation

Log in
Register


"Question everything, especially the price": Amid explosive claims of 'cash for questions', a storm engulfs Mahua Moitra, Hiranandani & the ever-eloquent Shashi Tharoor, as photos go viral and warships sail, political vendettas blur with personal tactics

Taking a swipe at Moitra, some internet users said that there is something "cooking" between Shashi Tharoor and Mahua Moitra
 |  Satyaagrah  |  Opinion
BJP MP Accuses Mahua Moitra of ‘Taking Cash to Ask Questions’
BJP MP Accuses Mahua Moitra of ‘Taking Cash to Ask Questions’

In a startling revelation, BJP MP Nishikant Dubey has accused Mahua Moitra, the Trinamool MP, of being a parliamentarian-for-hire. According to Dubey, Moitra has a peculiar habit – she seemingly raises questions in Parliament, but only if her pockets are generously lined first. And who might be behind these alleged fiscal favours? Businessman Darshan Hiranandani, as Dubey claims.

On October 15th, the BJP representative didn't just stop at casual gossip. He formalized his allegations, submitting a complaint to Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla. His petition is crystal clear: he wants an inquiry against Moitra. And not just any inquiry. Dubey has urged for Moitra's immediate suspension.

Now, one might wonder if this is just another day in the political arena, where accusations fly faster than facts. Or could there be some weight to Dubey's claims? After all, politics, money, and gifts can sometimes be intertwined in the most unexpected ways.

But, setting the allegations aside for a moment, let's delve a little deeper into this narrative. The real question that bubbles to the surface is, why would Moitra, an elected representative, potentially risk her reputation for some extra cash? Could the allure of material gifts truly overshadow the responsibility she has towards her constituents? Or is this just another attempt to malign her image?

Mahua Moitra, known for her fiery speeches and staunch opposition to the BJP, has often been a thorn in the side for many in the Parliament. With Dubey's recent accusations, the political pot is certainly stirring. Whether these claims will boil over into a full-fledged scandal or evaporate as mere steam, only time will tell.

For now, the ball is in the court of Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla. As the nation watches with bated breath, it's crucial to remember the old saying, "Where there's smoke, there's fire." But then again, sometimes it's just a lot of hot air.

Dubey's letter pulls no punches, painting a picture of Mahua Moitra, not as a champion of the people, but as a player in a much larger game of corporate chess.

According to Dubey, Moitra and businessman Darshan Hiranandani have a covert arrangement. The alleged quid pro quo? Moitra raises specific questions in Parliament, and in return, enjoys the fruits of Hiranandani's generous gratitude - in the form of cash and gifts. These aren't mere rumours or whispered secrets; Dubey's claims stem from a letter penned by advocate Jai Anant Dehadrai.

The numbers, as Dubey presents them, seem eyebrow-raising. Out of 61 questions posed by Moitra, 50 appeared to be in service of Hiranandani’s company. And who often found themselves in the crosshairs of these questions? Rival business conglomerates like the Adani Group. The audacity of such a play, if true, is staggering. It paints a picture of Moitra as a master tactician, criticizing the government in public, accusing them of being in cahoots with business houses, all while allegedly furthering her own hidden agenda.

But here's where the plot thickens. Dubey implies that Moitra's outspoken critiques of the government might have been a smokescreen, a clever distraction from her own backdoor dealings. In essence, while she pointed fingers and shouted allegations, she might have been silently furthering her own interests.

Machiavellian Camouflage": Moitra's Alleged Parliamentary Pantomime

The political landscape is no stranger to allegations, but when they are as weighty and charged as those levelled against Mahua Moitra, they are bound to ignite fierce debates. The recent accusations made by BJP MP Nishikant Dubey are reminiscent of a dark chapter in Indian politics—the “cash for query” scandal of 2005.

Dubey's allegations are not merely about a simple exchange of favours. He contends that Moitra's actions in the Parliament represent a breach of privilege, contempt of the House, and a violation of Section 120-A of the Indian Penal Code. Such claims, if proven true, can have severe consequences on Moitra's political career and reputation.

The crux of Dubey's claim revolves around a supposed quid pro quo arrangement between Moitra and businessman Darshan Hiranandani. According to Dubey, this arrangement unmasks Moitra's public image, revealing a deceptive façade behind her perceived morality. He doesn't hold back, likening her tactics to a "Machiavellian Camouflage," insinuating that Moitra hides behind a carefully crafted image of a vociferous MP, while allegedly indulging in clandestine dealings.

But Moitra isn't one to back down without a fight. In response to the swirling maelstrom of accusations, she threw down the gauntlet, challenging investigative agencies like the ED and CBI to probe into her alleged misdeeds. However, she added a caveat: she'd welcome these investigations only after they delve into the Adani Group's alleged offshore money trail, over-invoicing, and benami accounts. Her fierce retort indicates a readiness to face her accusers and an implicit critique of their selective outrage.

Darshan Hiranandani: The Business Titan Amidst a Political Storm

The recent fracas between BJP and TMC MPs has inadvertently thrust a prominent figure into the limelight - Darshan Hiranandani. Beyond the political melee, it's pivotal to understand who this businessman is, and why he's now at the epicentre of this political maelstrom.

Darshan Hiranandani isn't just any entrepreneur. He stands at the helm of the Hiranandani Group, a real estate behemoth in India, with his legacy rooted in the visionary work of his father, Niranjan Hiranandani, and uncle, Surendra Hiranandani. Together, they've sculpted skylines, developing not just homes, but expansive townships, IT parks, and a myriad of other infrastructural marvels.

Educated at the renowned Rochester Institute of Technology, New York, where he acquired both his MBA and B.S., Darshan's profile paints a picture of a modern, global businessman. He didn't merely rest on the laurels of the Hiranandani legacy; he expanded and diversified it. Under his stewardship, the group ventured into international real estate and made bold forays into emerging sectors, from data centers and cloud computing to energy and industrial warehousing.

His LinkedIn profile elucidates his vision - a commitment to India's infrastructural evolution and economic growth. Furthermore, his entrepreneurial spirit is evident in the founding of innovative platforms like Tez Platforms, Yotta Infrastructure Solutions, and Greenbase - Industrial & Logistics Park.

However, now, his name is embroiled in a political controversy, a testament to the intricate tapestry of business and politics in India. As the story unfolds, it remains to be seen how this business magnate navigates the choppy waters of political accusations and continues his journey in the corporate world.

The Hawk Eye  @thehawkeyex, tweeted below information:

#CashForQueryScam

Mahua Moitra in serious trouble. No not because of partying pictures.

EXECUTIVE details in affidavit filed by lawyer Jai Anant Dehadrai, while Nishikant Dubey further wrote to LS speaker. This wont go well with MM:

  1. MM hatched conspired to ask specific queries in Parliament that helps profiting Hiranandani group in exchange of cash & expensive "gifts".
  2. ₹75L & ₹2cr cash indirect for election campaign appears as tip of iceberg
  3. Items alleged Gifted- iPhones, diamonds & emerald jewelry, luxury items such as scarves from Hermes & Louis Vuitton, about 35 pairs of shoes from Salvatore Ferragamo, dozens of bottles of expensive French and Italian Wines, packets of luxury cosmetics from Dubai, Bags from Gucci and crocodile leather bags from Berluti
  4. Regular delivery of cash packets both in ₹ & £
  5. Extensive designing & reconstruction of residence by the Hiranandani, substituted/paid by himself.
  6. 51/60 questions asked by MM, very personal & business specific to Hiranandani (details in afdvt).
  7. Questions designed such way to target Adani group, govt, bring out crucial info for Hiranandani's businesses directly from serving Ministers
  8. Some of queries directly pertaining to the legal case that Hiranandani is facing related to Revenue Authorities discovery of his undeclared offshore Trusts of over $60mn. The way MM rhetorically targeted Adani group was obviously motivated. The affidavit has granule details upto the gifted iPhone model names and places where the meeting taken place. Such bits-n-bytes revelations is only possible when someone very close to either MM ot Hiranandani has spilled the beans

The Hiranandani Controversy: Business Vs Politics

The recent scandal involving the Hiranandani Group and TMC MP Mahua Moitra has thrown a spotlight on the often-blurred lines between politics and business in India. At the heart of the storm are allegations that Moitra took bribes to champion the interests of the Hiranandani Group in Parliament.

However, both Moitra and the Hiranandani Group have come forward vehemently denying these claims. Moitra has stated her readiness to face any inquiry to clear her name. On the other hand, the Hiranandani Group's stance is clear - they've always maintained a distance from political quagmires. Their spokesperson was quoted by NDTV, emphasizing, "We have always been in the business of business and not in the business of politics." The statement underscores their commitment to working in tandem with the government for the nation's interests, rather than getting entangled in political imbroglios.

BJP MP Nishikant Dubey, however, paints a different picture. He alleges Moitra has been ardently defending the Hiranandani Group's interests, particularly in the aftermath of their energy and infrastructural contract loss to the Adani Group. To substantiate his claims, Dubey cites the alleged appeasement of Moitra by Hiranandani with a whopping sum of Rs 2 crore and luxury gifts, including a high-end iPhone.

As the lines between corporate interests and political loyalty become increasingly tangled, the public awaits clarity. The controversy raises pertinent questions about the integrity of political discourse and the influence of big businesses on it.

Moitra and Tharoor: Viral Pictures Stir Social Media

In today's digital age, it's not uncommon for pictures to go viral and create a storm, often leading to unwarranted speculations. The recent instance involving TMC leader Mahua Moitra and Congress stalwart Shashi Tharoor stands testament to that.

Pictures of Moitra and Tharoor sharing dinner at a restaurant have been circulating rapidly on social media platforms. The images, which seem innocuous, have been a fodder for trolls, leading to a frenzy of comments and insinuations. Some netizens have even gone to the extent of suggesting that something might be "cooking" between the two prominent politicians.

Reacting sharply to the wave of insinuations, Moitra placed the blame squarely on the BJP, accusing them of disseminating the cropped images to fuel unwarranted rumors. She took to social media to voice her concerns, criticizing the BJP's 'troll sena' for their alleged role in the controversy.

The location of the dinner remains undisclosed, adding a tinge of mystery to the entire episode. However, amidst the swirl of rumors and conjectures, Moitra's message is clear. As reflected in her sharp retort, she believes that women from Bengal lead authentic lives, free from pretenses. Her statement, "Bengal’s Women Live A Life, Not A Lie," stands as a powerful testament to her beliefs and serves as a timely reminder of the need for respect and privacy in public discourse.

Recent photographs of TMC MP Mahua Moitra and Congress leader Shashi Tharoor have made headlines, albeit for non-political reasons. The images, now widely circulated, capture the two leaders dining together, raising a toast. However, what could have been a simple private moment has become the epicenter of a political whirlwind.

Moitra's reaction was swift. She emphatically slammed the BJP and its IT cell for sharing these images, suggesting a deliberate attempt to malign her image. In a bold move, she challenged the party to reveal the entire context of the photographs by uploading the uncropped versions. This would showcase others present during the dinner, providing a fuller picture of the event.

Adding another layer to the controversy is a particular image showing Moitra with a cigar and champagne. Moitra was quick to deny smoking the cigar, pointing out her allergy to smoke.

A certain photograph, which conspicuously crops out an individual while focusing on Tharoor and Moitra, has further fueled speculations. Responding with her characteristic wit on Twitter, Moitra didn't just address the controversy but also took a playful jab, hinting at her sartorial preferences.

The essence of this entire episode underscores the invasive nature of social media in personal lives, even for politicians. While the intent behind such circulation can be debated, what remains undeniable is the resilience and audacity with which leaders like Moitra respond, turning the narrative on its head. One thing is clear: in the world of politics, every picture tells not just one, but many stories.

Taking to Twitter, Moitra addressed the situation with a mix of humor and candor. "Most amused to see some personal photos of me being circulated on social media by @BJP4India ‘s troll sena. I like green dress better on me than white blouse." she quipped. Her tweet didn't just stop at sartorial choices. She also pointed out the deliberate cropping of the photos, challenging the party to reveal the entire context.

The reactions to the images varied, with some users pointing out the health hazards of smoking. Moitra, in her characteristic forthrightness, clarified she wasn't smoking but merely posing with a cigar as part of a jest, given her allergy to cigarettes.

What stands out in this episode is not just the invasive nature of social media in politicians' lives but also the manner in which they choose to respond. Moitra's response exemplifies how politicians today are not just shaping political narratives but are also deftly handling personal invasions with a mix of wit and straightforwardness. Her tweet underscored a broader message - that women in Bengal lead authentic lives, unapologetically.

Ah, the labyrinthine corridors of Indian politics, where the line between theatricality and reality blurs! Enter Mahua Moitra, the TMC MP with a penchant for ruffling feathers. When accused of a cash-for-questions scheme, one might expect righteous indignation. But Moitra, in her signature style, pivots to her dinner escapades with Tharoor, complete with viral photos and wry jabs at her critics.

Was this a deflection, or a masterclass in handling controversy with panache?

Add to this mix, businessman Hiranandani, turning the plot thicker than a monsoon cloud over Kolkata. The tale seems less about potential impropriety and more a reflection of the tit-for-tat culture of modern politics. And in the midst of this whirlwind, Moitra's cigar – not smoked but merely posed with, becomes a metaphor for the situation: all smoke, no fire?

As the saga unfolds, one thing's clear – in the age of optics and social media warfare, it's less about the truth and more about who tells the most compelling story. And for now, Moitra seems to be holding the pen.

Support Us


Satyagraha was born from the heart of our land, with an undying aim to unveil the true essence of Bharat. It seeks to illuminate the hidden tales of our valiant freedom fighters and the rich chronicles that haven't yet sung their complete melody in the mainstream.

While platforms like NDTV and 'The Wire' effortlessly garner funds under the banner of safeguarding democracy, we at Satyagraha walk a different path. Our strength and resonance come from you. In this journey to weave a stronger Bharat, every little contribution amplifies our voice. Let's come together, contribute as you can, and champion the true spirit of our nation.

Satyaagrah Razorpay PayPal
 ICICI Bank of SatyaagrahRazorpay Bank of SatyaagrahPayPal Bank of Satyaagrah - For International Payments

If all above doesn't work, then try the LINK below:

Pay Satyaagrah

Please share the article on other platforms

To Top

DISCLAIMER: The author is solely responsible for the views expressed in this article. The author carries the responsibility for citing and/or licensing of images utilized within the text. The website also frequently uses non-commercial images for representational purposes only in line with the article. We are not responsible for the authenticity of such images. If some images have a copyright issue, we request the person/entity to contact us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and we will take the necessary actions to resolve the issue.


Related Articles

Related Articles




JOIN SATYAAGRAH SOCIAL MEDIA