India has, time and again, witnessed the violent repercussions of so-called blasphemy accusations, particularly when it comes to criticisms of Islamic figures. One of the most alarming incidents in recent times unfolded in 2022, when Nupur Sharma, the then spokesperson of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), found herself at the center of a storm. Her remarks about Prophet Muhammad and his wife Ayesha—made during a TV debate—sparked unprecedented rage among Islamists. What often goes unmentioned in the mainstream narrative is that her statement was a direct response to Islamist Taslim Ahmed Rahmani, who had been mocking the Shivling discovered at the Gyanvapi complex in Varanasi. The selective outrage that followed, however, did not address this provocation but focused solely on Sharma’s response.